Paul Clüver Seven Flags: Greatness in Youth

One of the most ponderously predictable phrases in the world of wine, besides “wine is made in the vineyard” and “picked at optimal ripeness”, is the one claiming “this wine needs more time”. My simple summation of anything in my glass is that if it ain’t good enough to drink now, it is not going to be good enough ten or fifteen years down the line.

A good red wine, I use this example because the people asking for “more time” usually state this when approaching a red, should be a good wine on the day it is released. Because with all the modern skills and technology and farming know-how, there is no reason to bottle a wine that is not totally approachable in its youth. This is especially appropriate for those wishing to convince younger consumers of the magical essence in wine. Try gaining a wine drinker by telling him or her “it’s too young, but will be better in a few years from now”. This is as fatal as telling those thriving in a modern world that tattoos should be banned and Flat Whites should be decaf.

The recent release of Paul Clüver’s Seven Flags Pinot Noir 2025 shows that such young wines of noble profile and top-end ambition not only prove that these early ones are approachable, but also underscore the fact that wines of youth can be absolutely brilliant.

Not being a critic, analyst, note-taker or boffin, I largely rely on anecdotes from personal experience to lead an opinion. At the recent launch of the Seven Flags Pinot Noir 2025 – and Chardonnay – my first taste of the Pinot Noir had me abruptly halt a conversation I was having with Dr Paul Clüver. “Doctor,” I said during our chat on Roald Dahl’s contribution to neuroscience, “this is the best Pinot Noir I have had from your property.”

Before getting to the wine itself, I must recall the comments of the great Andrew Jefford on the virtues and splendour of young wine. In his seminal book Drinking with the Valkyries Jefford writes: “I love youth in wine, and everything that goes with it: the energy, the excitement, the flesh, the vivacity, the extravagance. Texture in wine is a particular delight. The profoundest pleasures in red wine are derived from tannins, assuming that those tannins are the consequence of a season spent ripening in the summer sunshine, and drawn unhurriedly and unfrenziedly from the slow bath of vinification.

“I love to feel them on teeth and tongue, giving the fruit a dignity it can acquire in no other way, and somehow evoking (both by texture and by strangeness of flavour) the natural milieu in which vines find themselves.”

Now, I am not wont to put wine in Jefford’s mouth for appraisal, but the above words precisely describe what I experienced in the Seven Flags Pinot Noir 2025. Only 21 months since the grapes were picked, nature, the mysteries of vinification, barrel-ageing and the intuitive skill of Paul Clüver cellarmaster Andries Burger have aligned to create a Pinot Noir of splendour, and magnificence.

Of course, the comet 2025 vintage helped. A mild growing season following a brutal cold and wet winter set the tone. Some spring rain slowed things down in the vineyard, holding back ripening, allowing flavour, tannin, sugar and acid to develop to pinpoint precision. In the cellar, the fruit received the usual degree of respect and care. Six-day cold maceration. Manual, twice-daily punch-downs during fermentation. 12 months in barrel, 47% new.

The result is a Pinot Noir displaying Paul Clüver Elgin terroir – cold above, Bokkeveld shale soils and clay down below – and the visceral, unbridled beauty of pure Pinot Noir driven by a winery where skill meets a seemingly inbred ethos allowing the team to truly understand the great red grape of Burgundy. The end-product showing those who drink it why the winery’s obsessive love of the variety matters.

Andrew Jefford

Exuberance, that particularly lovable aspect of youth, is evident on the nose, an aroma of brightness and swagger, wafts of broken rock, potpourri and wet kelp rising from the glass. Flavours are beguiling, joyous in the way acid, tannin and vivacious fruit flicker, prod and seduce the senses. There are lots of red things going on here, namely cool cherry and damson, a kick of sour plum easing into a luxurious, relaxed swell of honeysuckle and fig-paste, coaxing and comforting and wrapping the whole experience in a cloak of deliciousness. Sure, that cloak is now linen, but for those who wait, this wrapping will turn to silk and then to velvet. But why wait, I ask.

Back to Jefford: “Who doesn’t enjoy being invaded by a young wine, and having your head turned, your horizons altered, your composure rattled?

“Acidity in wine is never better than in youth, when it, too, remains spliced to generous fruit contours, indeed when it seems to bubble and froth with fruit itself, like a gurgling baby with milk. I can’t claim that a wine’s aromatic allusions are maximised in youth, since great old wines can be scented and resonant, too; but the very lack of serenity and harmony implied by youthfulness is a joy in itself, as you can pick out so much in the merry mix.”

With the benefit of hindsight, and a few days of further exposure to this wine: the best from Paul Clüver and, possibly, the best from South Africa. And I, for one, can’t be accused of harbouring the arrogance of youth in saying so.

Enjoyed this article?

Subscribe and never miss a post again.

Loading

9 Cape Winemakers Guild Wines to Punt On

The show is on. Cape Winemakers Guild season, and with the auction beckoning in October a selection of wines crafted by the Guild’s esteemed members was recently laid out for scrutiny. Your intrepid reporter scored an invite to this gig and decided that some gold reserves are to be cashed and Cape buffalo bulls sold to bid on the following stunning nine CWG vinos:

Kershaw Wines Ziggurat Chardonnay 2022

A master at work. And working well. Richard Kershaw takes grapes from Hemel-en-Aarde Ridge – Corton Charlemagne clone, to boot – gives them a whole-bunch squeeze and natural ferment. Bung in Burgundian barrels for 12 months with rigorous assessing done every eight weeks. As can be expected the paint is still wet on this master-piece, but signs of greatness are evident. The steely thrust of polished power, a neurotic edginess verging on the dramatic and electric rays of green citrus-peel, smashed almond and sun-baked buffalo skull. The most fantastic Cape Chardonnay in a long, long time.

Bartho Eksteen Vloekskoot Sauvignon Blanc 2022

The only Sauvignon Blanc in this year’s CWG offering, yet shows this variety has a role to play in the organisation’s lofty ambitions. Grapes from the Hemel-en-Aarde Valley give momentous cool-climate flavour, with whacks of buchu and thyme joining grapefruit and gooseberry to offer a delectable juiciness. A slight salt-lick maritime edge adds to the deliciousness and drinkability, although a few years in the bottle will re-invent this wine as an austere Sancerre-like classic from the south.

Paul Clüver Wagontrail Chardonnay 2022

Andries Burger has made this wine a perennial CWG classic and vintage 2022 is unique in that the vineyards from which this Chardonnay is vinified are now 35 years old – the first commercial Chardonnay sticks planted in Elgin. All the classic features of Wagontrail are evident: the yellow citrus on the nose, honey-suckle and bitter-orange on the palate with a whisper of Meursault-like nuttiness. But vintage 2022 has a flirtatious complexity that I can’t recall this wine ever having, as if some Turkish delight, persimmon and green plum has joined the fray to offer a seductive and very beautiful white wine.

De Grendel Op die Berg Pinot Noir 2021

CWG member Charles Hopkins shows his versatility as a winemaker with a brilliant Pinot Noir made from grapes sourced from the Witzenberg mountains, the vineyard just shy of 1000m above sea-level. Hopkins does Shiraz, Sauvignon Blanc and red Bordeauxs at exceptional levels, but somehow, I think he’s outdone himself with this Pinot Noir. Scintillating stuff, with a brooding power waiting to pounce as the wine ages yet already offering enough sour-cherry, brittle pine-cone and seedy Marseille musk to make the wine evocative and vivacious with a long run of polite refinement.

Erika Obermeyer

Erika Obermeyer Wines Silver Linings 2021

I want to use an infantile expression like “fuck me, sideways”, and I shouldn’t.  But hell, this is a marvellous wine. The blend is Syrah-dominated at 63%, with Grenache and Cinsault filling in the gaps plus a teensy 3% Cabernet Sauvignon. Not much information is available about the wooding, but this red wine is crafted with masterly skill by someone with the soul of an artist and an eye for beauty. A comforting plushness on the palate leads to that sensual grip of supple tannins as dark fruit – plums, currant, mulberry – oozes into the mouth, cut with a riveting line of pine-needle freshness. Truly gorgeous.

Newton Johnson Family Vineyards Sandford Chardonnay 2021

Gordon Newton Johnson gets lotsa mileage for his perfumed Pinot Noir, but I’ve always reckoned Chardonnay is the best grape on this Upper Hemel-en-Aarde property. And getting this wine selected for CWG duty vindicates my assertion. It is Chardonnay greatness on every level and the offering of this greatness looks just so damn easy. The nose is a medley of floral aromas with a mouth-watering edge of burnt-butter. In the mouth a hospitable, broad generosity pumps nutty, citrus and floral flavours while a cool lasso of steely minerality keeps things fresh, wanton and very much alive. Take me to the edge of heaven…..

David Finlayson Wines Inkunzi Tempranillo 2018

The Zulu for bull, is inkunzi, and this wine has the biggest balls of any of this year’s CWG offerings – except possibly for Donovan Rall’s pony-tail look. Aged for four years in oak, as per a Rioja regime, this Tempranillo is brooding in colour and already shows enormous power in its feral tannic scent. The attack on the palate is about as coy and genteel as an Eben Etzebeth clean-out at ruck-time, but thundering tannins and a vice-like grip are tempered by succulent black fruit and a hit of paella spice, finishing with a musky sliver of freshly sweated flamenco dancer. The biggest and most unique wine on show, and a keeper. No bull.

David Finlayson

Kanonkop CWG Paul Sauer 2020

No surprises in this selection as this wine is the CWG’s hottest item, and that includes Sam O’Keefe. Vintage 2020 has Paul Sauer, made by Abrie Beeslaar, once again showing a low-alcohol refined elegance allowing one to ascertain the splendour and beauty while the wine is in a state of youth. Calm, polite and cool, Paul Sauer 2020 brings autumnal dark fruit together with graphite and oyster-shell to make for a wine of such classic profile that it can make a Rasta DJ switch to violin music. A whiff of oak still drifts on the surface, but a dive into the still depths reveal awesomeness where taste, mouth-feel and beauty await.

De Trafford Glenrosa Syrah 2021

This number from David Trafford is one of those wines that defies corralling into a grape varietal or a region in that it is just such a super offering transcending preconceptions and borders. As Terry Theise wrote, many wines let you hear their noise, but only the great wines allow one to hear the silence. And this is one of them. A shy, yet intriguing nose of damp, dew-wet plum grove. On the palate the wine coaxes with silk-lined tannins while a resounding power reverberates across the senses. Dark, deep and mysterious flavours evoke the will to pry, search, but the joy is right before you.

David Trafford

Enjoyed this article?

Subscribe and never miss a post again.

Loading